HILDA REILLY
  • Home
  • Books
    • Prickly Pears of Palestine >
      • How it all began
    • Seeking Sanctuary >
      • Moving to Sudan
      • Attending a zar party
    • Guises of Desire >
      • A stage hypnotist sets the scene
      • Bertha witnesses an operation on her father
    • At Home in Khartoum >
      • Chapter 1
      • Chapter 2
      • Chapter 3
      • Chapter 4
  • Reviews
  • Interviews
  • Research blog
  • Travel Blog
  • Contact
  • New Page
    • New Page
  • New Page
  • Travel Blog

hysteria - signpost to the solution of the mind-body problem

4/9/2015

0 Comments

 
I’ve recently become aware that the current incidence of the hysteria diagnosis is even more common than I had once thought. When I was writing Guises of Desire my thinking was along the lines of the ideas discussed in Eliot Slater’s classic paper of 1965 which dismissed the hysteria label as a ‘disguise for ignorance’. Now, while researching the case of another patient from the early history of psychoanalysis, I’ve discovered a slew of articles in medical journals which indicate that about a third (figures vary) of patients referred to neurological clinics with suspected epilepsy suffer from what is now called psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (PNES) or sometimes nonepileptic attack disorder (NEAD). 
To be more specific, PNES represent a sub-category of conversion disorder, the name which replaced hysteria. The striking thing about PNES is that for most people, even doctors, the symptoms are virtually indistinguishable from epilepsy and patients can often be treated with epilepsy medication for years before it becomes evident that their condition is not epileptic. The main differentiating characteristic is that epilepsy is associated with abnormal electrical discharges in the brain; in the case of PNES there are no such discharges and it is generally believed to be caused by some kind of psychological stress, although this is by no means certain – or at least not in all cases. 
This doesn’t in any way undermine Guises of Desire as a novel as such diagnostic issues don’t enter into it. The narrative merely dramatises Bertha Pappenheim’s symptoms and those symptoms would remain the same, whether she suffered from a form of epilepsy or from PNES.
One of the difficulties for people affected by psychogenic disorder is the often implicitly critical nature of the discourse around the subject. A recent book on PNES, written by a neurologist, is subtitled Real Stories of Imaginary Illness, a description which homes right in on the problem. Apart from the offence it gives to patients, it suggests that there is nothing medically or physically wrong.
Such thinking reinforces the kind of dualistic approach which is so unhelpful in these cases – the idea that mental phenomena and physical phenomena are quite distinct. This can further lead to the idea that you are somehow the willing agent of your own mental phenomena, in contrast to physical phenomena which happen to you whether you like it or not.  
All experience – motor activity, emotional and physical sensations, and cognitive processes – is associated with neurophysiological substrates and if we could identify all the neural mechanisms involved in PNES we might at last be heading towards a solution to the mind-body problem – an exciting prospect. 

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    hilda reilly

    This blog discusses my research on two patients from the early history of psychoanalysis: Bertha Pappenheim, aka Anna O, and Anna von Lieben, aka Cäcilie M. For Bertha Pappenheim, the posts focus on questions related to Guises of Desire, my biographical novel about Pappenheim which I developed for an MA in Creative Writing.  For Anna von Lieben the posts are linked to my PhD research. 



    Archives

    December 2024
    March 2023
    February 2023
    December 2015
    September 2015
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.